November 2015

Short thought

Pp. 29-30 of HE Green Paper show that stuff on fee "incentives" is about de-funding. All stick with little carrot for existing institutions.

Short thought

Giving closing keynote at SCONUL winter meeting tmrw. Theme is "disruptive innovation". Ug. I'll be asking: who will disrupt the disruptors?

Short thought

Quite an incredible day for OLH behind the scenes. #cryptic I know, but more soon. Now off to celebrate @the_blochian's book launch.

Short thought

Talks this week in Amsterdam, Aberystwyth and London. We'll also announce the result of the first @openlibhums Library Board vote.

Short thought

Speaking in Amsterdam tomorrow. Got the new Foucault and Neoliberalism volume lined up for the journey...

Short thought

Many of the questions aren't answerable before metrics and process have been decided, which is deferred as a detail in the GP.

Short thought

The more I read the Green Paper, the more I see it's just a range of desired behaviours with virtually no details of the implementation.

Short thought

Very pleased to have been appointed to the UK's English Association Higher Education Committee for a five-year term.

Short thought

Have had 2 bad @british_airways trans-at flights this week. 1st: no working light or screen. Now stuck on tarmac for 2 hrs for engine prob.

Short thought

Nurse review treads the difficulty political ground: it's, err, not a merger but looks quite a lot like one.

Short thought

Very pleased to have been able to help in a small way in #opencon org committee. Pic by Slobodan Radicev CC BY.

Short thought

10,000-15,000 new DOIs registered every day. This is a complex map, notes @jenniferlin15. #crossref15

Short thought

Now @juretriglav up talking about @CokoFoundation at #Crossref15. Modernize and democratize knowledge creation.

Short thought

Publisher talking about doing plagiarism checks at the point of revisions, because that's where they're sure it will go ahead #Crossref15

Short thought

But does this change social perception of DOIs? Most researchers have no idea what these things are & just see many URIs. #crossref15

Short thought

Lots of talk about "best practice". Sceptical of this discourse; what does it mean? If it's "best" then can it be contested? #crossref15

Short thought

Today at #CrossRef annual meeting I'm talking about the "metadata deposit experience" for small publishers.

Short thought

Not even process of "review" should override that, let alone e- vs. non-e. Of course, I do encourage them to read the scholarly lit!

Short thought

When my students cite non-peer-reviewed items but do amazing work w/ them they can have credit. It's thought/research that matters not form.

Short thought

US meetings famously start early, but when jetlagged I end up going "full hobbit". (Two breakfasts b/c I'm hungry around 4am!)

Post

It is no use trying to replace the Impact Factor

At a session at OpenCon last weekend we discussed how to replace the impact factor. While the actual title of the session was "Taking on the Impact Factor", the subtitle was "how do we reform research assessment?" This gets to the heart of the matter and I wanted to jot a few notes.

Short thought

Had a great few days at #opencon - very pleased to have helped in small ways. And to have met @mbeisen!

Short thought

While we're on projects: I'm still interested in establishing a BitTorrent-based digital preservation system for OA articles & data #opencon

Short thought

But producing versions for different audiences & seeing how they propagate (& encouraging this for societal good) may be worthwhile #opencon

Short thought

Altmetrics can be a good idea alongside stratification of research outputs. Some basic res. will never score well with AMs. #opencon

Short thought

To answer Sweeney's Q: I want a world where everyone can read our work & the university is better integrated with society. #opencon

Short thought

When did the option of a scientific retraction as a practice of professional academic publishing become available? #opencon

Short thought

Thanks to "slippery rails" and all trains cancelled, I'm now running very late for my #OpenCon flight :(

Short thought

Farewell to committed Pynchon reader & well-loved community member, Dave Monroe (1966-2015). We will miss your warmth & enthusiasm.

Short thought

Thanks to all who listened to my talk. Not sure it was the most coherent I've ever given, but then I don't feel great today,

Short thought

Tomorrow I'll be speaking on the Cambridge University Press live stream about the future of open access. Sunday, speaking at OpenCon.

Short thought

When I taught at Sussex @SouthernRailUK train was late every week. Doing journey for first time in years & today a delay + cancellation.

Short thought

Along other things, academic panic around APCs & BPCs is exposure to a previously hidden, systemic, but devalued inequality of access.

Short thought

Up and off to Sussex nice and early today, reminding me of my first university teaching job there. Can't say I miss the journey.

Short thought

Great evening on a panel with @monarchomach @sarahchurchwell @gregg_sh @LyndseyStonebri & @pipwillcox. Thanks to @jfwinters for organising!

Short thought

Of course, it's abolish it for existing. Wouldn't want people digging into those new providers, would we?

Short thought

But we make existing institutions that do that accountable via FOI. So should we introduce FOI it new entities or abolish it for existing?

Short thought

Don't you just love how the logic in the green paper goes: so, we're giving private entities access to public funds via the loan book.

Short thought

Can't say how exciting it is writing up journal migration proposals (subscription -> OA) for our OLH library board. Feels wonderful.

Short thought

Just replaced the academia dot edu link on my blog navbar with my @MLACommons CORE deposit list.

Short thought

A correction to my post, which I will update as soon as I can get to a computer. Seems Elsevier bought North Holland in the 80s, not 90s.

Short thought

Hearing about digital critical editions of the work of Aleksis Kivi now. TEI encoded of course.

Short thought

Love it when a press release goes: you just don't understand, poor things, here are some FACTS. Usually signals untrue drivel to follow.

Short thought

Clear that the sentiment data of "like" is more useful to profile users and sell than the ambiguity of star/fave.

Short thought

Excited to be soon putting four previously subscription journals to our first @openlibhums library board vote for flip to fee-free gold OA!