December 2014

Short thought

Graun piece says FB shouldn't apologise for year in review. Argues that if you upload pics of someone who dies you deserve to be reminded.

Short thought

Unbelievably lazy programming on Radio 4 at the moment. "Phone in to tell us how you shopped at Christmas". Really?

Short thought

That was my evening's worth of 140 character armchair ranty Twitter philosophy. And very enjoyable it was too.

Short thought

Not against thinking, writing, theorising. But theory is very good at rationalising the always-deferral of praxis.

Short thought

I've concluded that we can't make ethical claims for our work based just on theory. The world is going to hell & won't fix itself.

Short thought

Much humanities discourse generates strong leftist (in non-technical sense) theory. What assessable (for centre-right) praxis might result?

Short thought

Theory, in all forms, is important. Academics are encouraged to write it, in various forms. Is "impact", though, an assessment of praxis?

Short thought

"since the Association is
dependent on the income from its publications ... Open Access to academic publications poses a
serious threat"

Short thought

More seriously, I thought Paddington was a lovely film. Capaldi great as the man who votes fascism without thinking it through.

Short thought

Perverse thought: REF is upside down. If we want to bring the quality of all universities up, we need to invest in weaker institutions.

Short thought

Cameron praises "giving, sharing and taking care of others". I thought we were all for letting migrants drown when I last looked.

Short thought

Time away in Peak District would have been better if I hadn't been unwell and laid up for our entire trip.

Short thought

STEM allowed to stay safe in short run. That is, until industry decide that it's too "monopolistic" for them to get state funding.

Short thought

The teaching grant is long gone, so of course it makes "sense" to next withdraw QR funding from Hums.

Short thought

Rewatched Lord of the Rings. Aside from being overly long & keen on monarchy, noticed all the heroes are white. Most of the villains aren't.

Short thought

If computer refuses to run disloyal software, it violates own principle of loyalty. If user must choose, then computer can be disloyal.

Short thought

Some of this seems to be about hardware & some, like remote attestability, software. In this case, who decides whether software is disloyal?

Short thought

Interesting new essay from Stallman there. Some contradictions though? What if the user orders the computer to run a "disloyal" program?

Short thought

Thought for the season: it's ok to hate league tables and REF, until the results come out and you've done well.

Short thought

Thanks so much to @mweller for organizing our webinar just now. Was good fun! And thanks to all who came and listened.

Short thought

Things I did not know before: one of the originally suggested names for the Open University was "The University of the Air".

Short thought

"Britain's burden", "helping the UK to project soft power", "must get over [...] post-colonial guilt", "importing/exporting students".

Short thought

Also, disclosure claims that VC of a UK university "does not work for any company or organisation that would benefit from this article".

Post

My 2014 round-up

2014 was a good year for me. I spent my time mostly working on scholarly communications projects, including the meTypeset software for the Public Knowledge Project and then establishing the Open Library of Humanities with a grant from the Andrew W. Mellon Foundation. I was in two minds to post this…

Short thought

"Financial Conduct Authority says conduct of Blackrock MD fell short of standards expected in the City". £43k fraud nowhere near enough.

Short thought

Rival ads for extra runways at Heathrow & Gatwick. Not even selling something in present. Advertising for political influence on future.

Short thought

Dislike would alienate users who provide valuable data while FB can still get its negative signalling privately.

Short thought

The reason there's no "dislike" on Facebook: "liking" is not a signal to other users, it's to FB. They already have a "hide this" option.

Short thought

"Lord West says UK agents may have been present during waterboarding – but there is no need for new inquiry". Oh, that's OK then.

Short thought

Good lord. I'm not kidding. That video in last RT is called "Dashboarding for Peak University Performance"

Short thought

After all, if they want to make it an age split (it isn't - know many older people who pursued PhDs), then people starting now have fees.

Short thought

Dodgy proxy measure of PhD for competence aside, wonder if that tribunal will consider whether it actually discriminates against the young.

Short thought

Reconciles panic over APCs with not only a solution but also an analogy and a counter-rationale to classical economics/competition.

Short thought

Thinking in terms of risk pools now seems to me very important. Wish I had more of that in the book but it's only become my focus recently.

Short thought

"Is the digital medium pushing journalism/the media towards superficiality?", asks Radio 4. Have they looked at the print media recently?

Short thought

Another interesting diff between monograph sale & journal subs: you know what books you're buying unless big deal but not which articles.

Short thought

The only thing scarier than remotely reconfiguring network interfaces is remotely reinstalling GRUB. sudo reboot. #phew

Short thought

Does anyone have any data on how much income small-medium sized learned societies receive from publishers?

Short thought

3. One of the roles of LIS and the library should be to teach researchers how to distinguish based on more than these proxy measures.

Short thought

2. It's only possible because we prefer modes of blind review that are cloaked behind journal brand/publisher name.

Short thought

More on "predatory journals": 1. who is actually surprised that anyone can put up a website or print pages and call it a "journal"?

Short thought

Among the things I don't love: ezproxy urls in article/book bibliographies. Couldn't publishers strip these out as a value-adding activity?

Short thought

Another good example of why publish doesn't mean "make public". Things that are in "print" and public can be re-published. @michaelbhaskar

Short thought

Save the date! Saturday 7th February: Supposedly Fun Things, a colloquium on David Foster Wallace.

Short thought

News. Racism. The brutality of the British state forcing the poor to food banks. The risk of accidental nuclear strikes. Police violence.

Short thought

Every time I write a webapp I'm impressed with Django, up to a point. All the basics are really easy but complexity soon mounts.

Short thought

LRT: thank you to @JoVanEvery to reminding me of today's National Day of Remembrance and Action on Violence Against Women in Canada.

Short thought

Reading and enjoying @JoannaFreer's Pynchon and the American Counterculture on my train journey.

Short thought

Also, I spoke too soon. Print copies of Open Access and the Humanities arrived today. Very fine they are too!

Short thought

Things I didn't know: Belgian PhD students get a very competitive salary to make it financially appealing. Want to retain best students.

Short thought

But now I'm extremely sad reading my feed. Police literally getting away with murder, again. Peaceful protesters being attacked.

Short thought

I had a wonderful time in Leuven speaking about OA and @openlibhums today. Thank you @viroviacum!

Post

The tension between dissemination and measurement

I remain firmly convinced that many (but not all) of the economic problems of scholarly communication are linked to the fact that academic outputs are both vessels of communication and objects of measurement. This is most manifest in the way in which publications are used as measures of worth in…