September 2014

Short thought

Saw the Inherent Vice trailer. Am still unconvinced the film will be any good. (Of Pynchon's novels, it's among the weaker books.)

Short thought

A certain nominative determinism in the headline "Conservative MP Mark Reckless announces that he is leaving the party to join UKIP".

Short thought

After talking to URI about @openlibhums yesterday (& seeing the Whitman 1st ed!) I got to visit HP Lovecraft's grave.

Short thought

Have, though, finished Mitchell's The Bone Clocks while waiting for the AmTrak. Thought it fizzled out a bit in the last part, but v good!

Short thought

Other projects have attempted to tackle this problem too. See @fiduswriter for example. @authorea #rwob

Short thought

Know a few people who would contest @albertopepe's blasting of LaTeX, even if it is good for a laugh #rwob

Short thought

Innovative journal platform for multi-media project was pulled and made into a VC-funded startup. Lesson: temptation to sell out #rwob #argh

Short thought

Also stumbled upon this wonderful early-twentieth-century, over-sized, faux gothic cathedral. #historicalimaginary

Short thought

Thanks to all at #COASP for an interesting and enjoyable conference. Will be at the final lunch, so do say hello if you haven't already.

Short thought

I'd add to this presentation: Humanities publishers are using XML (often JATS), they just aren't exposing it. #COASP

Short thought

I don't suspect, for instance, that there is any serious room for not-for-profits in his worldview. #COASP

Short thought

Aspesi, of course, sees the market as a neutral system. Total tension with the public good that I want from ScholComms #COASP

Short thought

Aspesi says that IF/outsourcing of hiring/firing is biggest block to change in academic publishing. #COASP

Short thought

Oh great. Aspesi warns not to be complacent; another financial crisis could be just around the corner. #COASP

Short thought

Tipping point for #OA in Europe was only last year. Mostly green. Think Aspesi is over-estimating how much change we should have seen #COASP

Short thought

I'd argue that there are often competing goals for OA movement. Centre-right govs. want it for v. diff reasons to left-advocates #COASP

Short thought

Aspesi says that he isn't sure what the goal of OA movement is: many different goals. Why should there not be multiple goals, though? #COASP

Short thought

Aspesi says that subscription publishing remains healthy but that full gold OA poses a large threat to their profit margins #COASP

Short thought

Elsevier and Wiley's shares continue to do very well, despite massive incursion of OA, notes Aspesi #COASP

Short thought

Aspesi predicts far lower impact from #OA than many claim #COASP (but then he isn't a researcher w/out access, he is interested in markets)

Short thought

Had a very nice evening with @OpenBookPublish, @gbilder and many others at #COASP - probably geekier than it should have been but good fun!

Short thought

Pinfield discussing public audience for medical literature. Some claim that this isn't important. Suspect @McDawg would disagree. #COASP

Short thought

African Journals Online now planning continent-wide OA strategy. Impact Factor does huge damage to African journal publishing #COASP

Short thought

African researchers pressured to publish contextually relevant material but in overseas journals. #COASP

Short thought

Extremely difficult to recover costs in any form in African journal economy - APCs and subscriptions both very tightly squeezed. #COASP

Short thought

Frontiers has a "young minds" project where kids write reviews of scientific articles. Brute honesty apparently! #COASP

Short thought

RS: "Kinda hard to find advertisers for a mathematics journal" [I'm also not convinced in any way that it's a good idea] #COASP

Short thought

Question from the floor re. advertising and its role in OA models for socs. Royal Soc.: haven't tried. #COASP

Short thought

We're warned that the British Ecological Society will conclude "hooray, but..." on OA. Wonder whether that "but" might be finance... #COASP

Short thought

Struck by fact that challenges of efficient APC payment mechanisms similar to difficulties faced by Jisc Publication Router #COASP

Short thought

Attribution is a legal requirement in CC licenses. The question of /how/ to do this is left open, though, says @CarolineSutton #COASP

Short thought

Begins with analogy by @CarolineSutton on phone chargers; why not standardised? #COASP (answer is, I'd suspect, corporate lock-in)

Short thought

Putting research data in "cloud" could compound problem says @gbilder. Big dangers in lack of ownership linked to corp. finance. #COASP

Short thought

Google and other companies are a serious threat to good people (in BioMed) remaining in the academy. #COASP

Short thought

JATS extension about to be released to support data citation #COASP @axfelix @juancommander @booksprint

Short thought

I really hate conference wifi that aggressively blocks non-HTTP traffic. VPN/SSH dead in the water. Oh well.

Short thought

(Might be true, but I got sense that what was meant was that "science 2.0" [ugh] has to engage and take input? #COASP)

Short thought

"It is no longer acceptable for science to speak truth to power", apparently. Not sure if that was what was meant? #COASP

Short thought

10m lines of code involved in CERN reduction/analysis of Higgs data. Have to be able to check/verify that. #COASP

Short thought

Tim Smith from CERN outlining challenges of handling huge data (bit rot, format migration, power consumption) #COASP

Short thought

Interesting conjunction of OA monographs & textbooks
in @ucylpay's lib. pub. enterprise. Textbooks less, monogr. more, common in hums #COASP

Short thought

Thanks to Alma for the @openlibhums shout out, as well as @OpenBookPublish, @ubiquitypress & @KUnlatched #COASP

Short thought

Swan shows how little humanities material is available openly on the Web owing to STEM focus. This is very poor. #COASP

Short thought

Swan singles out humanities disciplines for library publication initiatives, specifically with regard to long-form #COASP

Short thought

Library-based publishing panel now at #COASP with the great Alma Swan kicking it off. University publishing not new, of course, she notes.

Short thought

Political/administrative drivers/constraints for SciELO include international environment, access, metrics, IF & prestige #COASP

Short thought

Latin America, with the great SciELO platform, proportionately publishes the most open access research. #COASP

Short thought

Will be tweeting OA stuff from sunny Paris and the #COASP conference for the next couple of days. Many friendly faces here!

Short thought

The only thing I'm going to add about #indyref is this, on the subject of leaders pledging devolved power.

Short thought

Can't reveal details yet (#tease) but had some /very/ good OLH news today. "I love it when a plan comes together".

Short thought

Paxman writes re. trend to erase national borders (in support of No vote). But he's a Conservative. Current gov has awful immigration stance

Short thought

One day I'm going to write up the /vast/ amount of behind-the-scenes work that we've put into @openlibhums already. Not today, though.

Short thought

Fascinating how, wherever OA emerges, you see the same concerns (some valid, some totally misplaced) and similar stages of acceptance.

Short thought

No matter how many times I go to Jisc, I get lost. I need a Journal Innvestigating Scholarly Cartography.

Short thought

When I was in my worst phase of rheumatoid arthritis I could barely walk. Got so many dirty looks for taking seat just while my wife stood.

Short thought

One of the best things about the Guardian's membership scheme is that Daily Mail is now true: you can be a "card-carrying Guardianista".

Short thought

Just had my @ONKYO_EU TX-NR807 repaired (HDMI board died, apparently). Stereo sounds like a thing of beauty again.

Short thought

I might not agree with that strategy, but SH has a plan, so I read his remarks in the context of its fulfilment.

Short thought

In other words, I understand it as a phased, considered strategy, not an absolute "everything, now" if that blocks future. @AmSciForum

Short thought

Listening to Knopfler's Sailing to Philadelphia. 1st time I heard it, by chance, was reading Pynchon's Mason & Dixon, on which it is based.

Short thought

Thanks to @hridigital for the #dhcshef conference. Definitely came away with some new things to consider!

Short thought

My train journey home is being vastly improved by The Orb's new live album, The Orb's Further Adventures Beyond Dark Matter.

Short thought

(Wary of that futurology because judgement of a "good" translation is social. Might be possible to gauge social preferences.) #dhcshef

Short thought

Tom Cheesman just posited that there will /never/ be adequate machine-translation of drama/poetry #dhcshef

Short thought

"Intelligence is light: reflection, vivid, enlightened, light, luminary, shine, lustre, glaring, clear, gleam" says @EllenBramwell #dhcshef

Short thought

Historical Thesaurus of English built from OED and Thesaurus of Old English. Much hand-coding in project, notes @marcgalexander #dhcshef

Short thought

Core output of project is large (10k+ records) database of links between conceptual categories #dhcshef

Short thought

Now @marc_alexander and @EllenBramwell speaking about @ahrcpress project "mapping metaphor with the Historical Thesauras" #dhcshef

Post

Define: impact

The extraction of use-value, exchange-value or surplus-value from academic research at sites distant from the university.

Short thought

Nesi's project couldn't yet solve IP problems; digitise at-risk maniscripts; transform letters to corpora. #todo #apply #dhcshef

Short thought

Copyright and privacy problems prevalent in digitization of migrant letter archives, says Nesi #dhcshef

Short thought

Nesi says that most migrant letter archives are not yet in suitable formats for corpus linguists #dhcshef

Short thought

Migrant letter collections span: hardcopy originals, scanned manuscripts, hardcopy transcribed texts, text files and XML files #dhcshef

Short thought

Nesi says these letters also reveal patterns of migration/settlement and shed light of processes of language variation #dhcshef

Short thought

Migrant letters span all social classes, express writers' identities & tell us about domestic life of period, says Nesi #dhcshef

Short thought

Hilary Nesi up first today at #dhcshef on "Digitising experiences of migration: the development of interconnected letter collections"

Short thought

(Real answer: teaching, admin, conferences, mentoring, travelling, living. Probably not playing "OA Lingo")

Short thought

Cogent OA email: "Ever wondered what other authors are up to when they aren’t writing and researching?"

Me: ha! Like that ever happens.

Short thought

... Have editorial apparatus, social modules etc. Most important, though, is strategic reading and interpretation #dhcshef

Short thought

Stoyanova says objectives of their encoding project is to navigate author design, have bibliographic network of refs #dhcshef

Short thought

That's not to mention marginalia and intratextuality notes Stoyanova. This sounds like a hideously arduous encoding effort to me! #dhcshef

Short thought

Stoyanova notes huge challenges of encoding intertertextual features of this genre, which is vast #dhcshef

Short thought

Zibaldone genre is unsystematized notebook jottings. Shares characteristics w/ encyclopaedia eg cross reference, says Stoyanova #dhcshef

Short thought

Typical TEI processing models: 1:1 mapping to other format; 1:many mappings; and many to many says @jamescummings #dhcshef

Short thought

TEI-simple suited to representation of some early modern and modern books. "Printed books by dead white guys" says @jamescummings! #dhcshef

Short thought

Even customisable down to element level, modifying attributes etc says @jamescummings. "Customised, but documented" TEI #dhcshef

Short thought

TEI's modularity currently being described by @jamescummings. Can include or exclude at the element level. #dhcshef

Short thought

First up today at #dhcshef is @jamescummings speaking on TEI processing models for scholarly editions

Post

Rancière misreading Kautsky?

In Althusser's Lesson, Jacques Rancière writes: "This reading of Marx via Althusser and Lacan does little more than give a new sheen to a thesis Kautsky had already defended: science belongs to intellectuals, and it is up to them to bring it to producers necessarily cut off from knowledge"…

Short thought

Looking forward to the "TEI Friday" session at #dhcshef. The punning name could only be improved if the session was hosted by Marc Records.

Short thought

Wittgenstein and family resemblance as a useful definitional grouping for DH?, asks @topshelver #DHCshef

Short thought

See Sula, C. A. "Digital Humanities and Libraries: a conceptual model", 2013, Journal of Library Administration says @topshelver #DHCshef

Short thought

Now @topshelver is talking about his efforts to make the library responsive to DH projects #DHCshef

Short thought

MESA could act as a potential host for medieval collections elsewhere. Get in touch with @leoba ! #dhcshef

Short thought

Wonder how discoverability of digital editions for medievalists might fit with @DOABooks ... #DHCshef

Short thought

Digital editions for medievalists are hard to find. MESA might help with that, says @leoba #dhcshef

Short thought

Ooh. ModsNet getting up and running to join Advanced Research Consortium ad Modernist resource #dhcshef

Short thought

Good point from audience: institutions need to facilitate clean url structures on digital projects. Not always the case. #dhcshef #spaghetti

Short thought

Recommendation to create a "foresight group" sounds a little as though it should have a crystal ball... #dhcshef

Short thought

Best practice resources for from Jisc's "Spotlight on the Digital" are available. Should be able to find them by searching! #dhcshef

Short thought

A collection can be poorly discoverable through trad. channels but have heavy social media use, notes @paolamarchionni #dhcshef

Short thought

Does anyone know whether this is for /all/ academic research or DH projects? I think I missed that... #dhcshef

Short thought

Headline findings: Google is main route to discoverability of resources says @paolamarchionni #dhcshef

Short thought

Quantitative & qualitative research. BUT: no access to usage stats for digital collections, says @paolamarchionni #dhcshef

Short thought

Hearing from @paolamarchionni from Jisc about project between Jisc, RLUK & SCONUL to define and identify discoverability problems #dhcshef

Short thought

A good bit of Fish vs Moretti on falsifiability of literary readings. @mandellc arguing middle ground. #dhcshef

Short thought

User-corrected OCR is done under license that gives XML as reward to correctors. Wonder how Proquest feel re massively scaling #dhcshef

Short thought

NINES builds genre categories by ingest, rather than imposing top-down taxonomy, says @mandellc #dhcshef

Short thought

Advanced Research Consortium does heavy lifting for index on 18th-C Connect, NINES, MESA and others, notes @mandellc #dhcshef

Short thought

Methotrexate was helpful, but badly tolerated. Then, in last decade, anti-TNF, B-Cell targeting, anti-IL6, anti-JAK. All go.

Short thought

Really interesting that, for decades after the 1950s, there was no real advance in treatment/understanding of rheumatoid arthritis.

Short thought

Got so keen writing that blog post on my phone on the Underground that I sailed past King's Cross and had to go back. On my way now though!

Short thought

"a cemetery in the year 2666, a forgotten cemetery under the eyelid of a corpse or an unborn child"

Short thought

Arriving at Cambridge always reminds me of my grandfather who would walk me when I was a child to Trumpington meadows to watch the trains.

Short thought

Security personnel at King's Cross now "tour" the station, rather than "patrolling" it. Which is so much less militarised and far nicer.

Short thought

one-way rhetorics of dissemination in #OA sat within histories of Marxism and anti-humanism. Which was fairly pretentious but interesting.

Short thought

Reading Ranciere on Althusser this morning, and having been reminded of Foucault by @ernestopriego yesterday, I wondered how the...

Short thought

Royalties on academic books are usually (rightly) tiny but anything I do earn on /OA and the Humanities/ will go to @ArthritisRUK

Short thought

As part of my work on #OA and humanities & forthcoming book, I'll be doing a tweeted talk tomorrow @cambUP_books 10:30-11:00. #openaccess

Short thought

This supposed independent Scotland "brain drain" seems to rest on dodgy premises. Like: academics can just move & Eng unis are flush w/ cash

Short thought

The LSE Impact piece about "humanities: don't moan, just do it" has a point but also seems dangerous for free inquiry & dissent.